We have been running 50 weight oil in all our rebuilt transmissions & tranfer cases for several years now. Most manufacturers of the older transmissions & T/C's are actually recommending straight 30, 40, or 50 weight heavy duty engine oil based on the temperatures they will be operating in. The original builder of the transmissions we build & use with our Cummins repowers were built by Spicer (now Arvin-Meritor) doesn't recommend any other oils be used. The original oil spec of years ago was 90 weight, now their technicians warn SPECIFICALLY against its use. Extreme pressure oils are NOT designed for trans & T/C use & can even damage the unit, such oils are to be used in differentials only.
We have found gear boxes run cooler & shift easier using these oils & have never had the first issue to arise from its use. The 50 weight specialty blend we use is simply engine oil with a few additional additives that inhances it for transmission use, manfacturers say it isn't really necessary to use this blend & that the engine oil is fine. We have always tried to go the extra mile to use lubricants we feel to be the best for a given application, we chose this oil as a little added insurance. We get it from Dyson Oil Co, Durant, OK. Their website is
www.synergenracing.com The representative we use is Roland Johnson.